Multiple PC idea brain storm

[Xanthea]

I guess it wouldn't be hard to increase the number later once people are satisfied that the sky isn't falling and the kinks are straightened out.

[puny]

option 3 with 2 pcs means that one could play 2 pcs back and forth on the same server? its not that i dont get it, its just that i want it clearified

[Rumple C]

The pcs couldnt be on the same server at the same time Puny. So could have 1 on BG, 1 on WHL. But not both on MS.

[kid]

but travling would be allowed between servers?
One on BG and one travling between MS and TSM or what not? allowed?
are we limited to a single server or can we move to another as long as our other PC has moved out allready? Any time limitations?
Any rules about having 2 PCs in two rival factions?

Not sure having two PCs is a good idea, but if you try to come up with a 2 PC rule lets make sure we understand what restriction, if any we are suggesting.

[hollyfant]

but travling would be allowed between servers?

It might be wise to limit the option of leaving a server with one PC, and immediately shipping in with the next.

[Rumple C]

Its all just ideas at the moment kid, hence the thread. But most people see it as the pcs can move around at will, but cannot be on the same server at the same time. Passing through the same server to somewhere else should be fine (just as it would be if you need to pass through a server you dm on). The burden of playing responsibly and without meta abuse will be on the player. Best to try to avoid a situation where your pc is on opposing factions.

I imagine something like a 7 day cool down period for leaving a server and coming in with the other pc. (but thats just one idea amongst many).

[Ithildur]

are we all in favor of 2 PCs? damn... I'd still go with one.

I'm sure many of us would still be fine with one PC for ALFA.

2 PCs opens up some possibilities, but... I seriously have to wonder if multiple PCs are to some extent counter-productive as far as an issue that we all agree is a high priority: getting more active DMs and story/character focused gameplay. That's not just a straw-man argument imo; speaking for myself, I only have so much time/energy and creative energy. I'm quite sure I'm better off focusing on RPing one, at most two PCs at a time while I'm truly committed to any significant amount of DMing that has any substance to it (which involves RPing multiple characters that I would hope are more than cardboard signs that say 'talk to me for xp and loot'). I'm sure there are some people who can pull off quality, in-depth RP of 4 PCs each involved in a plot on different servers while regularly running DM plots with substance and dozens of 3 dimensional NPCs, etc. but honestly I'm inclined to think 'quality over quantity' wins.

[Blindhamsterman]

In the current state of things, 2pcs, no temp retirement free travel between servers so long as the two are not on the same server seems like a good idea.

Much like some, I don't think I'll actually roll a second pc unless my plans fall apart entirely. But that's just because I don't have the time for two. I do see the necessity of it for folk with more time

[Adanu]

are we all in favor of 2 PCs? damn... I'd still go with one.

I'm sure many if not the majority of us would still be quite content with one PC for ALFA.

I seriously have to wonder if multiple PCs are to some extent counter-productive as far as an issue that we all agree is a high priority: getting more active DMs and story/character focused gameplay. That's not just a straw-man argument imo; speaking for myself, I only have so much time/energy and creative energy. I'm quite sure I'm better off focusing on RPing one, at most two PCs at a time while I'm truly committed to any significant amount of DMing that has any substance to it (which involves RPing multiple characters that I would hope are more than cardboard signs that say 'talk to me for xp and loot'). I'm sure there are some people who can pull off quality, in-depth RP of 4 PCs each involved in a plot on different servers while regularly running DM plots with substance and dozens of 3 dimensional NPCs, etc. but honestly I'm inclined to think 'quality over quantity' wins.

I have plenty of time to 'devote' to having two PCs. If you don't, hopefully one day you will.

That doesn't mean those of us who can shouldn't have the option.

[Stormbring3r]

Having multiple toons is a good idea.. How many PnP peeps have multiple Characters in thier Portfolio from playing over the years.. I have about 40 or so.

I say 2 PC's. Cannot play on the same server.. Can travel to the same server but cannot stay and RP for DM events. Also toons cannot be related in anyway shape or form.

I.E. Joe Bob on TSM server ubber high level fighter cannot leave a will giving all his possessions to Billy Bob the 1st level Cleric on BG. Even though Joe Bob's mother is Billy Bob's brothers sister and married to Billy Bob.

[Castano]

let's start with 2 PCs per player, but they must be on separate servers

I am open to 1 PC per server as it is easier to manage, we know where they live etc. but open to starting this experiment out small.

[Isenheart]

Voting for option 3 as well, with the limitation of not being allowed both characters at the same server.

[Adanu]

Having multiple toons is a good idea.. How many PnP peeps have multiple Characters in thier Portfolio from playing over the years.. I have about 40 or so.

I say 2 PC's. Cannot play on the same server.. Can travel to the same server but cannot stay and RP for DM events. Also toons cannot be related in anyway shape or form.

I.E. Joe Bob on TSM server ubber high level fighter cannot leave a will giving all his possessions to Billy Bob the 1st level Cleric on BG. Even though Joe Bob's mother is Billy Bob's brothers sister and married to Billy Bob.

I can agree to this;

[Swift]

I am open to 1 PC per server as it is easier to manage, we know where they live etc. but open to starting this experiment out small.

Until they start moving around. 1 PC per server with no ability to travel would feel even more limiting than what we already have.

"Id love to come play with you on BG, but my character there is an evil half orc so we wouldnt mesh anyway"

[Castano]

If you want the old style 1 PC with totally free movement, then do not roll a second PC. I do not want 2 PCs from the same player on the same server.